Irish Coffee Mocktail, Nonalcoholic Irish Coffee

Irish Coffee Mocktail

One of the most popular hot cocktails is the Irish coffee. This stimulating drink has an origin that is one part urban legend, one part recorded fact, all topped off with a healthy splash of clever marketing. In this blog we share the history of this bracing beverage, as well as our Irish coffee mocktail recipe – a perfect drink for sober beverage trends!

A mixologist spoons a layer of fresh cream on top of an Irish coffee cocktail, nonalcoholic Irish coffee example
A mixologist spoons a layer of fresh cream on top of an Irish coffee cocktail. Nonalcoholic Irish coffee gets the same treatment!

Want early access to flavor and beverage innovation, beverage development tips, and consumer insights? Then make sure you…

Join the Beverage Innovation Email List!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Who made the first Irish coffee?

Legend has it that an airport cook by the name of Joe Sheridan whipped up this cream, coffee, and Irish whiskey drink to warm delayed passengers on a dark and stormy night in Shannon, Ireland. An American travel writer named Stanton Delaplane tasted the creamy cocktail at the airport bar a few years later and became obsessed with perfecting the recipe. He brought his memory of the Irish Coffee flavor back to San Francisco and, with the help of Jack Koeppler, owner of The Buena Vista Bar, crafted an American version that catapulted the drink into local popularity. The Buena Vista is now synonymous with Irish Coffee in the United States, serving upwards of 2,000 cocktails per day!

It’s true, other Irish Coffee origin stories exist, but the aforementioned one has perhaps the largest following (and the longest legs). When it comes to cocktail history, who isn’t charmed over by lore and legend?

How to make a nonalcoholic Irish coffee

For St. Patrick’s Day (or any day), charm yourself with a nonalcoholic Irish coffee recipe that tastes as good, if not better, than the tipsy version. Just like the original Irish coffee, the quality and freshness of the coffee and cream have a significant impact on the cocktail flavor – so spring for the best! To capture some of the natural alcohol flavor, this recipe uses a dash of rum extract (although an ounce of nonalcoholic whisky would be a solid substitute, too). Sláinte!

Hoe to make an Irish coffee mocktail infographic
Nonalcoholic Irish coffee is easy to make – just replace the whiskey with rum extract or natural whiskey flavor.

Beverage development services

Need help formulating your nonalcoholic cocktail or low alcohol beverage? Our talented team of food scientists and flavor experts are skilled in the art of nonalcoholic beverage development. Contact us today to learn about our beverage development services.

Learn About

Irish Coffee Mocktail Recipe

Ingredients

  • ⅔ cup strong black coffee
  • 2 teaspoons light brown sugar
  • ¼ teaspoon rum extract
  • ½ cup heavy whipping cream
  • 2 teaspoons cocoa powder, for garnish (optional)

Instructions

  1. Fill a glass mug with ⅔ cup of hot coffee.  Add the sugar and rum extract and stir until dissolved.  Let the cup stand still until the mixture has completely stopped swirling.
  2. Meanwhile, beat the cream in a medium bowl until it’s thick and airy, but still pourable.  Pour it into a jug with a spout.
  3. Pour the cream over the back of a spoon right in the center of each mug.
  4. If desired, dust the cream with cocoa powder using a stencil, and serve immediately.

Yield

1 serving

Try Natural Bourbon Flavor

Are you formulating a nonalcoholic Irish coffee or low alcohol cocktail?  Create authentic whiskey taste in zero proof beverages with our natural bourbon flavor. 

Request A Sample

Request a sample of bourbon flavor – or any of our alcohol-inspired flavors – today!

natural bourbon flavor, flavors for nonalcoholic cocktails
White Spacer

Sign Up

Try this refreshing juniper and citrus gin flavor in your next nonalcoholic beverage application.  It makes a great alcohol-free Gin & Tonic, Gimlet, or Tom Collins!

Request A Sample

With warm notes of agave, hardwood, and wildflower honey, our natural tequila flavor can be used in applications where gold or reposado tequila is required.  It’s the perfect flavor for a nonalcoholic Margarita, Paloma, Tequila Sunrise, or Mexican Mule.

Request A Sample

With notes of rich caramel, dried fruit, and brown spice, our natural spiced rum flavor captures the best of Barbados.  The perfect choice for creating a nonalcoholic Mai Tai, Daquiri, Hurricane, or Mojito – or managing the freeze point for Rum Raisin ice cream.

Request A Sample

Our natural vermouth flavor is bursting with layered cherry and wine flavor.  Pair it with our natural Bourbon flavor to craft the ultimate nonalcoholic Manhattan cocktail, or our natural gin flavor to make an alcohol-free Negroni.

Request A Sample

Our natural rosé flavor helps consumers drink pink, without the alcohol!  With notes of ripe strawberry and wine, it’s a sophisticated choice for the best beverage, confectionary, frozen dessert, and sweet sauce applications.

Request A Sample

Dry and crisp with just the right balance of fruit and toast, our natural champagne flavor adds sparkle to a variety of applications.  Try it in everything from nonalcoholic Mimosas to gummy candies and sweet tea – even cakes and ice cream!

Request A Sample

Bold and smoky with notes of molasses and vanilla, our natural bourbon whiskey flavor takes you deep into the mountains of Tennessee.  Don’t make a nonalcoholic Manhattan, Old Fashioned, or Mint Julep without it!

Request A Sample

With just the right balance of caramel malt and hop notes, our natural beer flavor captures the essence of the classic pale ale.  Whether used in a nonalcoholic beverage or specialty cheese dip, beer flavor is sure to deliver!

Request A Sample